Pool Care /
How to choose a pool cleaner for your pool
Choose the right pool cleaner by matching debris type, pool equipment, and how much maintenance you’re willing to do. Safety and compatibility matter most.
Archive date: this article was written for PoolSkimmer on Oct 24, 2026 and given the earlier archive date of Aug 28, 2025 so the blog reads as an organized archive. It was not published on that date.
Selecting the right pool cleaner
The ideal pool cleaner is one that you can put to use safely and keep up with, rather than the model boasting the most features. It should be suited to your routine and the demands of your pool. Hayward puts it in perspective by dividing automatic cleaners into three categories: robotic, pressure, and suction.
Where to begin
Look at the state of your pool and its surroundings first.
- Debris: You will have different needs for fine dirt, which requires a brush before vacuuming, than for leaves or insects that call for more frequent skimming.
- Surfaces and floor: When debris has a habit of settling fast, a surface tool will not do; you need something that makes regular contact with the bottom.
- Shape of the pool: Ladders, steps and narrow corners can get in the way of some cleaners.
- Your setup: Be sure your pump, filtration, skimmer and any ports are up to the task of running a particular cleaner without issue.
Even the best cleaner cannot do everything if you have a lot of windblown or tree debris. In those cases, stick to regular basket cleaning and skimming.
Robotic, suction or pressure?
These are the three options on the table.
- Robotic: Independent of the filtration system and what Hayward calls energy-efficient.
- Suction: Tied to a dedicated port or skimmer via the filtration system’s flow. This is the most economical choice according to Hayward.
- Pressure: Requires a line from the filtration system and in most cases a booster pump as well as the pool pump.
If the requirements of the cleaner and your equipment are not in sync, do not try to make it work. Consult the manual or a pro.
The maintenance factor
A cleaner is meant to take some of the burden off, not add to it. Consider whether you are inclined to:
- Keep the skimmer basket in order.
- Give the pool a brush prior to vacuuming when called for.
- Clean out the filter or collection chamber as you should.
- Have a unit that operates on its own versus one dependent on the pump.
Hayward would also point out the value of a clear skimmer and the right water level for proper circulation. Debris is only collected effectively if the rest of the system is in good shape.
Making a purchase
Use a checklist so as not to overbuy. Verify that the unit is compatible with your pump and can cope with your pool’s floor and debris. Make sure the manufacturer’s instructions are straightforward and that the parts are easy to service. Do not be swayed by promises; see if the product is a good fit for your pool and your capacity to maintain it.
Time to call in a professional?
If you have questions about plumbing, an odd skimmer arrangement, or circulation issues, let a qualified pool professional handle it. The same goes for any sign of electrical trouble or damaged gear.
Whatever you decide on, safety comes first. Never put a hand into operating suction equipment. Turn the pump off to get to the skimmer basket, wear the appropriate PPE and adhere to the owner’s manual and chemical labels.
Sources and further reading
- [Hayward: Weekly pool maintenance](https://www.hayward.com/maintenance/weekly-pool-maintenance)